What actually happens when your child dies a preventable death in an NHS hospital?

[Written 21.6.15]

After listening to Scott Morrish describe his experiences of what happened after his young son, Sam, died a preventable death in hospital (a depressingly, depressingly familiar account), I thought it might be useful to try to capture and summarise the process. What actually happens:

  1. Your child dies. Unexpectedly. Horrifically. Sometimes brutally.
  2. You are traumatised. Pitched into an unimaginable space of deeply intense pain, shock, horror, disbelief and agony.
  3. Your body expels anything it can physically; vomit, tears, shit, noise.
  4. And, from this point, for a potentially infinite period, you live a life that is, at best grey.
  5. The Trust responsible for the ‘care’ of your child will speedily present a ‘Shame but nothing to see here’ type line. 
  6. There may or may not be talk of an investigation or ‘root cause analysis’.
  7. You will probably start to ask more focused questions.
  8. The response to such questioning can be anything (or shift) from faux assurance that everything possible is being done to get find out what happened, to hostility or simply silence.
  9. The process seems to be continually delayed by the actions of the Trust. They fail to disclose documents or complete versions of documents. You become more concerned and continue to question.
  10. A narrative soon surfaces. You’re the problem. You, with your persistent questioning, your inability to ‘move on’. Your unreasonable actions are causing problems for others, including the staff involved. 
  11. There may be attempts to smear/discredit you through nuanced reframing or positioning of events or explicit blaming.
  12. If the investigation finds that your child’s death was preventable the Trust may apologise (probably publicly if the report is made public). The superficiality of this apology may become apparent when the Trust pitches up to the inquest with barristers and coached staff in an attempt to refute any real responsibility.
  13. The NHS, that cuddly British institution that you’ve grown up with warm fuzzy feelings and respect for, is not your friend when something goes catastrophically wrong.

Wow. Just bleakly bleak. With a load of bleak on top. Despite detailed NHS policy spelling out what to do. At the Clinical Human Factors Group conference that Scott was speaking at, one man told us about his experience after his wife died. The Trust were completely open, took responsibility for what happened and worked with him in investigating her death thoroughly and transparently. He emailed me after and said “I know that my journey was made easier by the commitment and personal philosophy of some staff in the hospital trust.”

So it can be done.

The big question is why does it tend not too?

[Three years on and no answers…]

4 thoughts on “What actually happens when your child dies a preventable death in an NHS hospital?

  1. Your description is my experience. A timeline of incidents and events where the risk of a fatality was left to happen. It was my sibling who was the victim but could have been any one of the six people with profound learning disabilities abandoned in a pit of degradation. The fact admitted by a member of staff that the house team had been ordered not to talk to the legal advocate
    clearly leads directly to why an on the spot doctor wasn’t called out at the advocates behest. Multi agencies charged with ensuring vulnerable people are safe failed one decrepit ex ATU.

  2. Pingback: The pursuit of justice – phsothetruestory

  3. My experience of a cover in October 2014 up after two months in an NHS Trust in Surrey is very similar. Staff and executives in the Trust covered up for the negligence of a consultant. The PHSO later failed to carry out a competent investigation.. I am lucky to be alive but now have several disabilities as a result of the failure of my GP and hospital staff to diagnose sepsis.

  4. Our son died. He could have been saved 3 times by being told that the lesions that were removed from his legs and shoulder could be a link to a genetic cancer. HLRCC.
    This is not right. Some people say well the dermatologists weren’t inclined to learn this bit of research.
    This is wrong too. Why do you get paid? To do your job whatever it may be. If you do not you have failed. The dermatologists and the oncologist who did not have knowledge of HLRCC took our son away from us.
    None of us should stand by and be complacent. Our hurt continues 5 years 3 months on. All we want is for someone to apologise. Is SORRY the hardest word for the NHS and PHSO
    We feel the pain of all those who hurt.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.